Missing Persons Commentary

Memberships to get behind paywalls can become expensive. Support the website. Fund future research into true-crime mysteries and unsolved missing persons cases.

This Day in True Crime History (Nov. 17)|H.H Holmes is Arrested

By: Shane Lambert
Original time of publication: November 16th, 2026

Looking back, what significant events happened in true-crime news on November 17th?

November 17, 1894: H.H. Holmes is arrested

On November 17, 1894, one of America’s most notorious early serial killers was arrested in Boston, Massachusetts. The man was known as H.H. Holmes, although his real name was Herman Webster Mudgett. His arrest would eventually expose a disturbing trail of fraud, deception, insurance schemes, and multiple murders that stretched across several American states.

News did not move quickly in the media in those days. However, his arrest was documented by sources. If you look at the source below, it says he was “arrested in Boston fr swindling an insurance company” out of a sum of what appears to be $10,000. In 2026’s terms, this would be almost $400,000 using the CPI Inflation Calculator.

Holmes would never regain his freedom. His murder trial began in Philadelphia on October 28, 1895, where he faced the charge of murdering Benjamin Pitezel. The proceedings attracted considerable public attention, and an artist’s courtroom illustration depicting Holmes during the trial appeared on the front page of the October 30, 1895, edition of The Philadelphia Times.

On November 2, 1895, Holmes was found guilty of Pitezel’s murder and sentenced to death. He would remain imprisoned until May 7, 1896, when he was hanged at Moyamensing Prison in Philadelphia.

Leave a Reply